Observations from the other side of the audition table…


This past week, we had two days of auditions to find new singers to add to the roster of Olde Towne Carolers.  The business has been growing steadily each year, and last season we had to turn down some last minute gigs because we just didn’t have enough singers to accommodate the demand.   Since starting the business in 2005, I’ve never held auditions.  I’ve always used my singer friends, or singers that they referred to me.  So it was kind of scary holding open auditions.  I didn’t know how comfortable I’d be with letting total strangers into my little family of carolers.  Could I trust them to represent my business out there in front of the public?  But you can either take the opportunity to grow, or stay in the same place and stagnate.  There was only one course – grow!

Holding auditions was very enlightening.  Now I know this wasn’t like a normal opera audition, so we didn’t need to hear if people could sustain a high D or sing insanely difficult bel canto or baroque melismas, but there were other important things to listen for, and other factors that didn’t even have to do with singing.

Here are a few observations, in no particular order….

– As far as first impressions on your personality; if you are friendly, we will like you!  If you are mean, we won’t like you.  Seems pretty simple, huh?

– Don’t come into an audition with a chip on your shoulder, bad attitude, and sense of entitlement.  Even if you sing well, we won’t want to work with you.  And if you have that much attitude in an audition, how will you behave around clients and their guests?  Will I have to deal with your bad attitude every time I call you for a gig?  And none of the other singers are going to want to be on a three hour gig with you.  Sorry, but no.

-I had some of my good singer friends that are in the group helping me with the auditions – inside the room and outside.  We’ve all been there, done that.  We want you to succeed and do well.  And we all listen with the ears of trained musicians.  We’ve been singing these pieces since I started the group.  We can tell a lot in just a short period of time.  We don’t need to hear song upon song upon song to make our decision.  (And since one of my good singer friends was also working the waiting area, we know which singers are making negative comments, and which ones are professional and polite.)

– We totally understand that you are nervous!  We are singers too!  We completely take that into consideration while we listen.  I mean, what singer hasn’t experienced the effects of insane amounts of adrenaline impacting the voice?  We also understand allergies, and colds, and all that crap.  During December (aka: Caroling Season – insert scary music here), there’s always at least one of us going through some kind of ailment at any given time.  It’s how you can sing WHILE feeling the effects of said ailments that makes for a great proving ground.

– Just as I tell my voice students – no one is perfect, but it’s how you recover from mistakes that is a true sign of professionalism.  We chose a difficult piece for the singers to sing acappella.  There were a few mistakes, but the singers who recovered well and held their own despite any little flaws impressed us as much as the ones who sang it perfectly.

– Wexford Carol is one of my absolute favorite carols.  So I wanted to know that each singer we took could do this one.  Plain and simple.  Plus, it’s more difficult – it was one that showed us which singers could learn music well and accurately.

– Please dress up for an audition.  Not formal wear (thank God no one made that faux pas with us), but I did see some too-casual outfits.  Would you wear denim to a job interview?  An audition is a job interview.

– It really is true – there are so many sopranos.  80% of the singers that auditioned were sopranos.  I feel their pain.  It’s my life too.

– We were really impressed with the singers who were intuitive and observant during the group singing.  Which singers noticed and caught on the the group dynamic changes and followed the tempo changes?  That really influenced our decisions.

– Look engaged when you are singing.  If you have a blank stare the entire time, why would people want to watch you sing?  We loved the singers that smiled and had genuine joy in their faces when they sang.  That’s what we want from our singers at the gigs!  Most of the people who hire us are not professional musicians, they want decorations that sing pretty.  (Yes, an oversimplification, but there’s a lot of truth in it.)

– Some of the final decisions really came down to availability.  If two singers are of equal ability, we’re going to take the one who has the weekend availability.

– People were coming from all different backgrounds, and I noticed that when I got their resumes.  In strict performance circumstances, your singing resume should be one page.  That’s it.  (This was drilled into me when I was in Conservatory.)  If you have more than a page’s worth of credits, trim them down.  But we had people who were singing for us from different backgrounds – you could tell which ones were coached in this particular aspect of the biz.  This did not impact our decisions, but it was something I observed.

So those are my thoughts right now.  If I think of more, I’ll add them.  But overall, it was a very interesting experience.  And I really did get to be reminded that the people on the other side of the table really are just people.  As a singer, when you go into the audition room, it’s hard to remember that most times.  But I was wondering why people would be nervous to sing in front of little ol’ me!  Hopefully this experience will make me less nervous in my own auditions.  (A girl can dream, right? haha!)

Photo of author
Jennifer was initially drawn to Europe for two reasons: music and love.  She lived in Vienna for four years, and now calls Croatia home for much of each year, as she married a native Croatian. Since 2015, Jennifer has worked as a tour director and cruise director on European river cruises for a major American travel company, and has become an expert in all of the cities along her routes on the Danube, Rhine, and Main Rivers. She also has traveled to Disney World almost every year since 1985, and knows Disney World inside and out. As a travel agent, Disney World is her primary specialty, and she has helped many Disney newbies and veterans have amazing trips with her insider information.

2 thoughts on “Observations from the other side of the audition table…”

Leave a Comment

Want travel tips backed by 15 years of expat & travel industry experience?

Get my best tips and updates sent straight to you!

coming soon!